在“大图画”上,李常受基本是承接并放大倪柝声的“永恒旨意/经纶”路线,但在语言密度、系统化程度、教会实践与边界画法上,明显走得更远,也由此产生出既连贯又紧张的“传承与分歧”。[1][2][3][4]

## 一、共同传承:同一条“基督—生命—经纶—召会”主轴

– 两人都从以弗所书式的“神永远计划”出发,强调:神在永远里定意要把基督作生命分赐到人里面,产生并建造基督的身体,终极是新耶路撒冷。[5][6][7]
– 在实践上,都把“地方教会生活”看作执行这永恒旨意/经纶的具体场所:
– 经历基督作生命;
– 在地方召会里建造身体;
– 以教会见证对付撒但,等候主再来。[3][8]

可以说,李的经纶观在大框架上,是在倪的“永远旨意—地方教会”骨架上加厚和细化,而不是另起炉灶。[2][1]

## 二、李对倪的放大与系统化:从“永远旨意”到“神圣经纶高峰”

– 倪多用“永远旨意/神的计划”词汇,结构虽清楚,但较少用“经纶”作技术性术语。[6][9]
– 李则明确以“神圣经纶(God’s economy)”为中轴,将倪原有线索系统化:
– 把“三一神经过过程并终极完成—作生命分赐到人里—建造身体—终极新耶路撒冷”讲成一条高度完整的经纶叙事;[10][5]
– 在八十年代提出“神圣启示的高峰”:神成为人,人(在生命性情上)成为神,以产生团体神人、新耶路撒冷。[11][12]
– 这等于把倪原本略带“属灵神学+圣经神学”色彩的经纶观,推进成一个高度系统、本体论张力更大的“神人观—经纶三一论”,这是明显的“超发展”。[4][13]

## 三、教会实践上的承接:地方教会作为经纶程序

– 倪:地方教会(一城一会、反宗派)是“永远旨意在地上的合宜显出”,重点在“捍卫身体的一与见证的纯一”。[14][15]
– 李:完全承接此点,并进一步说:
– 地方教会是“进入身体实际”的程序与步骤;
– “地方召会是程序,身体实际是目标”,强调在地方召会中要被“引进到身体的实际”,以达经纶的高峰。[8][16]
– 传承处在于:两人都把地方教会看成执行经纶的中心平台与地上路径;差异在于:李更明确把“地方召会—身体实际—高峰启示”抽成一条连续阶梯,话语上集中度更高、运动意识更强。[16][8]

## 四、主要分歧与张力(供你课堂或论文使用)

### 1. 经纶内容的“高度”与语言胆量

– 倪:
– 用语多停在“与基督联合、基督作生命、教会作身体、新妇、团体人”,较少用“人成为神”这类高张语言;[17][6]
– 即便谈“神儿子的许多弟兄”,也基本在罗马 8 的儿子名分与形像层次。
– 李:
– 在经纶高峰上大力使用“人成为神(在生命与性情上,非在神格)”“团体神人”等表述,借此表达信徒在经纶中被构成,与三一神生命性情相同。[12][11]
– 这种语言既有东正教神化论的回声,也引起广泛争议,被很多人视为比倪更“前推一步”的大胆发展。[13][4]

### 2. 地方教会与“职事中心”的加强

– 倪:地方教会论已很强,但在他亲自带领阶段,“职事中心”更多落在人格魅力与事实上的影响力上,话语上仍强调“主的工人不过是肢体,权柄在教会中”。[18][14]
– 李:
– 在承接“一个职事”的同时,更系统讲出“当代职事/流”的概念,将经纶异象与特定职事传统(Nee‑Lee)紧密捆绑;[19][20]
– 在全球扩展地方教会的过程中,形成了一个高度集中于“职事话语—出版事工—训练体系”的运动结构。
– 这样,倪强调“地方教会为经纶的显出”,李则在此上叠加“职事作为经纶的解释与推动轴”,经纶观与特定话语体系的关联度明显提高。[1][5]

### 3. 高峰启示与末世论期望的收紧

– 倪:永恒旨意—得胜者—国度赏罚—新妇的结构已经很浓,但仍与更广泛福音派末世观有一定对话空间(强调得胜者,却保留较多开放性)。[21][17]
– 李:
– 把“高峰启示+神人生活+照着神牧养+新复兴”连成一条高度内聚的末世性路线,话语上较倾向将“主恢复中的高峰经纶”视为主再来前关键见证;[12][16]
– 这样,实践永恒旨意在话语上与特定传统的末世角色绑定更紧密,拉开了与一般教会的距离。

## 五、一句综合命题

> 在“实践永恒旨意”这条线上,李常受基本承接并放大倪柝声的主轴——同样以神在基督里的永远经纶为中心,以地方教会为执行场域,并强调基督作生命与身体建造;然而,李一方面对经纶内容作了高度系统化与本体论上的推进(如“人成为神”“经纶高峰”等),另一方面又在教会实践上加深了“职事中心+地方召会程序+身体实际目标”的结构,使得永恒旨意比在倪时代更紧密地与特定话语体系和运动形态相连。于是,两人之间既有“经纶异象与地方教会实践”的明确传承,也在经纶高度、三一—人论用语与教会结构集中度上呈现出不可忽视的分歧与张力。[2][8][11][1][12]

Sources
[1] A Concise Presentation of the Teachings of Witness Lee and the … https://witnessleelehren.org/en/introduction/
[2] Why We Read and Promote the Ministry of Watchman Nee and … https://shepherdingwords.com/why-we-read-and-promote-the-ministry-of-watchman-nee-and-witness-lee/
[3] THE BEGINNING AND THE END https://www.ministrysamples.org/excerpts/THE-BEGINNING-AND-THE-END.HTML
[4] Essence and Economy: An Introduction to Witness Lee’s Doctrine of … https://academic.oup.com/jts/article/76/1/238/8046240?rss=1
[5] THE ETERNAL ECONOMY OF GOD https://www.ministrysamples.org/excerpts/THE-ETERNAL-ECONOMY-OF-GOD.HTML
[6] Major Teachings – Watchman Nee https://www.watchmannee.org/major-teachings.html
[7] Collected Works of Watchman Nee, The (Set 2) Vol. 34 https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-collected-works-of-watchman-nee-the-set-2-vol-34-the-glorious-church-Watchman-Nee-read-online/5/
[8] The Local Church must be a Testimony of the Reality of the Body https://www.agodman.com/local-church-testimony-reality-body-christ-oneness/
[9] God’s eternal purpose – The Bible — Recovery Version https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-collected-works-of-watchman-nee-the-set-2-vol-46-conferences-messages-and-fellowship-6-Watchman-Nee-read-online/15/
[10] Crucial Elements of God’s Economy, глава 3 https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-crucial-elements-of-gods-economy-Witness-Lee-read-online/3/
[11] Truth Concerning the Ultimate Goal of God’s Economy, The, глава 1 https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-truth-concerning-the-ultimate-goal-of-gods-economy-the-Witness-Lee-read-online/1/
[12] Living a Life according to the High Peak of God’s Revelation, глава 5 https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-living-a-life-according-to-the-high-peak-of-gods-revelation-Witness-Lee-read-online/5/
[13] Becoming God in Life and Nature: Watchman Nee and Witness Lee … https://www.localchurch.kr/theology/51308
[14] Watchman Nee’s Life and Ministry https://www.watchmannee.org/life-ministry.html
[15] Glorious Church, The – author Watchman Nee (W. Nee) read online https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-glorious-church-the-Watchman-Nee-read-online/
[16] The Highest Peak in God’s Economy: the Reality of the Body of Christ https://agodman.com/arriving-at-the-highest-peak-in-gods-economy-the-reality-of-the-body-of-christ/
[17] The Glorious Church by Watchman Nee | Goodreads https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/731042.The_Glorious_Church
[18] Collected Works of Watchman Nee, The (Set 2) Vol. 43 https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-collected-works-of-watchman-nee-the-set-2-vol-43-conferences-messages-and-fellowship-3-Watchman-Nee-read-online/6/
[19] Witness Lee and Watchman Nee, Two Ministers with One Ministry https://holdingtotruth.com/2012/10/19/watchman-nee-and-witness-lee-two-ministers-one-ministry/
[20] Watchman Nee and Witness Lee. The core matter that untied them … https://www.facebook.com/groups/60041033336/posts/10156457028228337/
[21] Chapter 7: The Eternal Purpose – Christian Classics Ethereal Library https://ccel.org/ccel/nee/normal/normal.xi.html
[22] Raising Up the Next Generation for the Church Life, глава 3 https://bibleread.online/all-books-by-Watchman-Nee-and-Witness-Lee/book-raising-up-the-next-generation-for-the-church-life-Witness-Lee-read-online/3/
[23] [PDF] We Were Wrong – Christian Research Institute https://www.equip.org/PDF/EnglishOpt.pdf
[24] Addressing the Open Letter’s Concerns: On the Nature of God (Part … https://www.equip.org/articles/addressing-the-open-letters-concerns/